Wednesday, March 04
O the creative temperament: child is supposed to have her own composition for an upcoming competition, but she suddenly HATES IT because it sounds like Baby Stuff, and the chord she stumbled across that really made it sound cool to me now strikes her as too dreamy. The song is cheerful but IT’S STUPID. Sounds like BOOK ONE. Tears. So we started something else, and once again – the virtues of mistakes and serendipity – she hit a note that gave it an extra dark zing, so we’re off on another tangent. I keep telling her it doesn’t have to be Beethoven.
I wonder what Beethoven’s friends told him.
Ordinary day, and absolutely nothing about the outside world to report. Right now I’m kicking myself for watching both hours of “24” last night, because that would have provided some late night entertainment. But no. I had to watch the Crack Elite Sangala Mole Men drill up into the White House and prove for the entire world that there aren’t any security cameras anywhere except in the chandelier over Plot Point Hall. I’m just wondering how that plan came about.
Men of Sangala. Draw near.
Ominous glowering maximum leader! How shall we strike?
We will take the President Hostage. In the White House.
Fortune favors the bold, sir. But how?
This I do not know. Get your men on it. Find some shadowy businessmen. They will help.
(The next day)
Good news, sir. We have located a tunnel that goes underneath the White House, but I don’t -
No contractions! We are Africans!
I am sorry. We do not know if it leads anywhere, but the person who gave us the plans -
It is pronounced Plons! We are Africans! How will they know we are Africans if we use contractions and say plans?
Sorry sir. The plons included a very large picture of the White House, so it must lead straight to the Executive wing.
Very good! I will relish this. Begin the complex series of terrorist events!
Tuesday was one long cold nut-studded cheese log, and the less said the better. Did what I had to do, and wandered through the day with the enthusiasm usually found in those frozen skeletons they unearth in Alpine glaciers. The week suddenly felt long and arid; the full weight and scope of MARCH stretched ahead unleavened by warmth or greenery. And then of course there’s the news. I think we enjoy the weekends so much these days because it’s a respite from the grand parade of craptacular stories that run M-F. Really: on Sunday night I get that sinking feeling when I realize that Monday will bring more horror stories. It’s our leading export!
I’m content for the moment to let other bloggers be furious on my general behalf, but I am damned tired of losing money, knowing I will have less money in the future, and what I do have will be worth less because of inflation. All of which means I save less, invest less, spend less, and give less. But that’s fine, since we all went mad Mad MAD in the last ten years, and now we have to atone. It’s the Guilted Age.
There’s the temptation to curl up in the cozy cave of the long-dead past, where nothing can hurt you, but that’s a coward’s dodge. Really, I don’t mean for this site to become one long saunter down Memory Lane. Too much nostalgia makes you feel out of sorts with your own time. When you return to the real world it’s like putting on work pants after a weekend in sweats.
And: Too much attention paid to the artifacts of pop culture gives them more weight than they had. At most I try to infer values and preconceptions from the movies and shows, not take their messages as The Way Things Really Were in the Perfect Age Before Hippies.
We can’t recreate context. A happy go-go camera ad may look groovy and all, and make people think gee, the sixties were fun! But you have to imagine it blaring out into a small shabby room with yellow carpet, where a guy in a stained T-shirt over a potbelly is eating Swanson’s off a folding tray. Outside, New Jersey. (The bad part.) All of this stuff was background noise. Life was then as life is now: work, food, family, leisure, heartbreak, sleep, backaches, cake, trouble abroad in some damn spot, worries at home over some damned thing.
Most of your life is spent trying to recreate the emotions of an imperfectly reconstructed memory of childhood happiness. The other part is spent trying to escape, or at least process and purge, an equally imperfect recollection of childhood unhappiness. Better to be driven by the former rather than the latter, obviously. And the more shapeless the emotion, the less specific the event, the easier it’ll be to recreate it, and the happier you’ll be. I find these artifacts of my very early youth so interesting because I had a happy childhood, and all these musical cues, hues, fabrics, patterns, et cetera, are the furnishings of a place I enjoyed. But they’re not important because they happened to me or any other late Boomer; they’re important because you can get some sense of the era by the objects it left behind.
If you want to, that is. Some people have no taste for studying the past, and that’s fine; others view it as a source of amusement, because they were stupid and we’re not and people had funny hair and it was sad that they didn’t have color or sound until 1952. These are the hopeless morons who type YouTube comments on keyboards filthy with nacho dust – except for the apostrophe and Shift key. They’re pristine.
Anyway. Yesterday I put up a picture, and wondered if anyone knew where it was from; of course, a few readers got it right away: it’s from the “Night on Bald Mountain” sequence in “Fantasia,” from 1939. For some reason the other night I watched part of the movie again. Googled around for some commentary, came across a piece that noted how odd it was to have a sequence about evolution then end with a note of religious belief. (Sigh. Yes, how do you square that.) The “Rite of Spring” section, carved up as it was and used for dinosaur images, was something I saw in grade school, and I remember how disturbing it was – not the images, which were great because you had dinosaurs fighting and then one of them died and then they all marched off in the desert and died and then mountains came up!
No, it was the music that unnerved. It’s the most frightening piece of music ever composed. Not zweet! zweet! Psycho scary, but ecstatically mad, communally cruel, godless, ignorant, passionate, full of horrible conviction. It’s everything inside us we need to keep hidden. I know it’s bad and unnatural and Herbert to repress our inner selves, but if there’s any species that needs to do a good & thorough job of repressing, it’s us. Otherwise it’s virgins down the volcano twice a year and three times if there’s an eclipse.
Here’s a YouTube clip with a better version of “Rite.” Listen for the timpani at 1:16: absolute bloodlust.
The Night on Bald Mountain sequence was always the show-stopper when I saw the movie on the screen, and “Ave Maria” was the itchy-church-pants part that undid all the cool darkness of the earlier part. Man, pass the collection plate already. Now I think it looks amazing; it’s one of the most beautiful sequences of animation ever created.

But that’s not the point here. I’m not sure what my point is, but I’m confident that if I write long enough, I’ll find one. Oh: right. Today at the Corner Derbyshire linked to an old Teachout piece on middlebrow culture, something we’ve knocked around here a bit. By the time I knew the word it was a term of derision, made suspect by the usual suspects: the effete pointy-headed nattering kabobs of elitism! Er, no. Well, sort of: it seems as if there was an odd decision in the sixties by the cultural elites to eliminate the middle and accentuate the lower, because the lower was more earthy and authentic and real. Intellectual slumming at its finest. I think the middlebrow spirit had run its course, too. It’s hard to tell people to better themselves when the rest of the culture is telling them they’re already great – or suffering some sort of oppression that can’t be cured by listening to Beethoven. So high culture drifted off into the ether, became formless and irrelevant, and low / pop culture became culture, period.
Ah, but once upon a time. The ultimate middlebrow moment:

Mickey and Stokowski. Hiya! Put ‘er there!

That’s how it worked: Mickey had to climb up; Leopold had to bend down.
Ach, now I remember what my point was. The Toccata & Fugue sequence, once my favorite, is now my least. But it ends with the images that made me want to be a conductor:


And, not incidentally, probably sent me off on the Path of Retro. Not just that, but this:

The streamlined mountaintop! The Cliff of Modernity! So much of “Fantasia” was my first exposure to the look of the 30s, and it seemed impossibly modern and ancient at the same time – the sets in the “Dance of the Hours” sequence were straight out of fascist neo-classicism, if you want to be honest. There was the idealized classicism of the kitschy “Pastoral” sequence, which managed to ignite my interest in classical architecture, which led to an interest in the 20s, where the forms and vocabularies were applied to Noble Civic Buildings and impossibly tall skyscrapers. Somewhere around this time I discovered the bound copies of LIFE magazine in the Fargo library, and that’s when the interest in the past began.
I just have to be careful not to spend too much time there. Even the greatest museum is still a graveyard.
Today: Minneapolis update around 1 PM; Out of Context Ad Contest around 11. Miscreant Roundup at buzz around noon-thirty, if work duties permit. See you soon!

Would Sen. Red Forman threatening to put his foot in Gen. Juma’s ass be too much to hope for?
Dave(in MA):
Ah, but he’s not playing Red, or anyone like him; he’s playing a guy in high dudgeon when _anyone_ gets a foot up the ass(especially Jack Bauer’s foot, it would seem)…
Seems to me there’s a movie to be made about the making of, and the premiere of Rites of Spring. You have a bunch of crazy Russians (Stravinsky, Nijinsky, Diaghalev), which is always good for a historical drama. The immediate reaction to the premiere of the ballet (it was a ballet first) included shock, anger, catcalls, seat throwing, and fistfights between those that supported and those that opposed the piece. The press after described a decadent display of gross sexuality and violent movement, plus the music was considered just as disturbing as you found it as a child.
A movie about those characters, set during the writing and first staging seems like a natural, wonder why it hasn’t happened?
I used to compete in piano competitions (years and years ago) and I never had the opportunity to compose my own work. It would have been awesome, actually. Alas, it probably wouldn’t have made me like competing any better. I hated it. Still do, as a matter of fact. Apparently Glenn Gould, the fabulously eccentric Canadian Bach interpreter, felt the same way as he suddenly stopped performing in public back in the sixties.
Somehow I don’t think any of this helps.
You could try coming up with something yourself that’s deliberately bad; so horrendous that, for fear of ever possibly having to play it instead of her own composition, she’ll be glad to accept virtually any combination of notes she herself strings together.
P.S. We’d love to hear her composition, if she doesn’t threaten you with disembowelment if you come within twenty feet of her with a recording device.
“Some people have no taste for studying the past, and that’s fine; others view it as a source of amusement, because they were stupid and we’re not and people had funny hair and it was sad that they didn’t have color or sound until 1952. These are the hopeless morons who type YouTube comments on keyboards filthy with nacho dust – except for the apostrophe and Shift key. They’re pristine.”
That’s the second funniest and insightful thing I’ve read this week (sorry). The funniest was Jim Treacher in the comments at Hot Air:
http://hotair.com/archives/2009/03/02/christopher-buckley-surprised-to-find-the-guy-he-voted-for-is-in-fact-a-statist-liberal/comment-page-1/
The point remains the same. Don’t learn from the past and you’re doomed to repeat it, or at least sound like an idiot.
“I keep telling her it doesn’t have to be Beethoven. I wonder what Beethoven’s friends told him.”
Probably “it doesn’t have to be Bach.” But that just begs the question back again.
“Herbert” as an adjective. Heh.
you know, this is really pretty mild for your repeating financial panic.
oh, that’s right, we have oversight now, the lying stealing weasels can’t try to corner the market on bubbles any more and take us all down with them. yeah, we don’t have panics any more, we have recessions.
except this has the hallmarks of a classic 1800s panic. no credit, the bankers are sitting on their (increasingly brown-stained) moneybags, but they still find time for parties and yachting while the ordinary jobs evaporate.
we need a classic 1800s response. Swordsmen on horseback riding through the exchanges! On, oh gladiators, for the Flag of the Tree! swish-swish-swish.
there, now I feel better. ready for a fundraiser at noon, and get the coolers ready for the quarter of beef I bought.
“Most of your life is spent trying to recreate the emotions of an imperfectly reconstructed memory of childhood happiness. The other part is spent trying to escape, or at least process and purge, an equally imperfect recollection of childhood unhappiness.”
I’m past that. I’m now trying to find some meaning in my work when it seems like everything’s going down the tubes. If not the economy, then global warming, if not warming, the decline in my in-laws and the need to consider Where To Put Pop. Oh, and the newspapers circling the drain. Can’t forget that.
Meanwhile, a line from Pink Floyd’s “The Wall”:
But I have grown older
and you have grown colder and
nothing is very much fun anymore
Thanks for the Password memories. That eased the pain for a bit. Maybe I can reboot for the rest of the day.
Too much nostalgia makes you feel out of sorts with your own time.
Shrug. Feeling out of sorts with our own time is something of which one should be proud.
I’ve always thought that nostalgia, or even just a desire to return to the past, was rooted in the knowledge that no matter how bad things may have seemed, everything ultimately turned out all right. World War One, the Great Depression, WW2, the Cold War… all things that seemed potentially endless while they were going on, but in the end most survived and went on to the next crisis. Living in the present has no such luxury.
Out of sorts with my own time? I wear a fedora while listening to OTR on my iPod — I take the best of all worlds and try to live in it today.
What I’m trying to say (pre-first coffee) — nice piece, James. Simultaneously catching the joys and troubles of nostalgia.
The “Guilted Age ” ?
Twain fans would have caught that pun ,and also spewed coffee.
It was his worst book BTW,(co-written) w the possible execption of a 30th
book that saw first light in 2001 .It should have remained buried .
I read the Oxford Twain a couple years back , 29 volumes .
Call it a “temptation to curl up in the cozy cave of the long dead past ” .
Most of his books could have been trimmed ,but he was paid by the word .
Still for me the thrill was finding a gem like the one buried in the above (screed)?
I confess that I followed not the musical links in today’s gush .
So I probably missed the finer points .
But having thrown away a decades work as embarrassing to my current standard
I can understand Natalie’s frustrations .
Having heard a few of your own above ,my advice is divide and conquer .
Specifically ,into 4 different columns .It will give us even more of you to love .
Oh , as a king of ephemera matched only by Jean Shepherd ,I hope you can take comfort in the fact that most of it will be greedily snapped up by one garage sailor or another , on down the road.
Your words however like Shepherd’s ,and Twain’s will remain your own ,
and outlive you .
It is because they were well spoken.
“It doesn’t have to be Buxtehude!”
Guilted Age
I get word play! And I tip my hat. Parts of this could find it’s way into screedblog, but you’ve leavened it with so much recognition of then, now, and tomorrow that it’s unnecessary. Symmetry and balance. Such a delicate thing to produce, but there it is. A fine piece. The Strib could not do worse by featuring it.
I fell out of my chair when I encountered:
… filthy with nacho dust – except for the apostrophe and Shift key. They’re pristine.
And I try to do my part by avoiding the Doritos and placing apostrophes, where needed.
I’m with you on “The Rite of Spring.” I like challenging myself with some of that crazy orchestral stuff, but as much as Stravinsky is IMPORTANT, I’ll skip it, thanks. It’s the part of Fantasia I always zip past. (Which has nothing to do with its bold pro-evolution statement that’s supposed to destroy my faith but so far has failed at it, . . . and everything to do with the fact that it’s ‘difficult listening music.’)
There is no doubt that our culture is waning. Until that changes, there’s no reason to feel guilty about indulging in (and drawing from) the past.
“Too much nostalgia makes you feel out of sorts with your own time. When you return to the real world it’s like putting on work pants after a weekend in sweats.”
James: The above quote from the bleat is just one of so many gems in today’s entry that I don’t know where to begin except to tell you that it’s an absolute joy each morning to experience a literary genius at work. Your stuff should be mandatory reading for anyone who has ever tried to accurately and cleverly express their thoughts into words. Thank you!
It was weird. As I was reading this Bleat, sitting in my living room with DirecTV’s XM Pops channel in the background, I heard Dukas’ “Sorcerer’s Apprentice” playing. Really. I can’t hear that piece without visualizing poor Mickey dealing with the endless line of water buckets and mops. Many days work felt that way, and I empathize completely.
“Middlebrow?” Yep, and proud of it. I can put down a copy of “Gatsby” and pick up a Louis Lamour without a twinge of conscience.
Maybe I am being naive but, there is nothing to learn from the future, only the past.
There are quite a few people re-discovering Ayn Rand and Friedrich Hayek in the present political climate. It is pretty clear that over 50 years ago, they “got it”
Instead of reading Atlas Shrugged or something, I watched the Mike Wallace Interviews with Rand from 1958 and with Phil Donahue and Tom Snyder in the 70s, good introduction and fun to hear her talking around the liberal icons of media (Snyder was the most fair, Wallace did not seem to get it). They are on YouTube.
In science, sometimes the young researcher will get a quick brush off from the older one and the younger interprets this as arrogance and being close minded. What the younger does not realise is that the older scientist has heard it all before, that is, been there, seen that, proved it wrong.
Often the same thing happens in politics when trying to deal with a younger person who thinks it all started right after the 2000 election.
I wonder what Beethoven’s friends told him.
It doesn’t have to be Salieri?
A stupendously well-written piece, James. I applaud you with great gusto. I think you need to write a book, or at least a collection of your posts. I would volunteer to promote it gratis to the local independent book stores in my metropolitan area (all 3 of them). Please consider it!
Middlebrow is alive, but on life support. Saw a commercial for the “100 Greatest Books” the other day.
Much of what we’ve heard about the initial reactions to the “Rite” may be historically exaggerated. There was plenty of displeasure with it, of course, but there were more than a few artistic elites who accepted the piece, else Stravinsky would never have made it to later successes. Also, it was scored as a series of “ancient tribal dances,” which would have made just as fascinating an interpretation in “Fantasia” had Disney so chosen.
One thing about Sorcerer’s Apprentice, though: my first reaction is almost never “Fantasia.” I was an old Sherlock Holmes (Rathbone) junkie, and our local TV station always played a clip from “Apprentice” as the theme before showing one of his films. Thus “Sorcerer’s Apprentice” equals Basil Rathbone, not Mickey Mouse.
It doesn’t have to be Haydn.
The Greats are an amazingly little circle of teachers and students as you read about them. This person was that person’s teacher, who taught them and so forth.
James, if you have not been introduced to the musical genius that is Beethoven’s Wig, run to Amazon as fast as your fingers type and do so. This insidiously wonderful brain worms will never let you hear “Moonlight Sonata” the same way again. There are four CDs all full of gems.
[...] produced the dreaded ManBearPig. Whom incidentally, was last seen around these parts at the end of this super-serial edition of Silicon Graffiti from June 3rd of last year: Filed under: Capitalism, the [...]
Towards the end of the Tocata in Fugue sequence from Fantasia, fireworks form a series of gothic arches that echo the gothic arches in the Ave Maria sequence (you can see at least one in the still that James has posted). Both Tocata & Ave Maria end with dawn and the sunrising.
In a nutshell that explains the death of middlebrow culture. Around the middle of the last century the cultural elites decided that any Haute Ecouture that was intelligible to the bourgeois was failing in its mission to be critical of bourgeois values.
And look where that has gotten them.
Woody, was that one of the Los Angeles independents? Channel 9 I think, could have been KTLA 5.
That’s funny. I’ve been reading Twains’ autobiographies and I remember a thinking ‘this stuff reads just like Lileks.’
The Gilded Age, not so much.
That’s it: I’m taking “Fantasia” out of my kids’ Netflix queue…
I suspect that Beethoven’s friends told him to stop sounding like Mozart. Some of Bizet’s friends probably said the same thing.
Fantasia was and remains one of the best movies ever made, and the best animated film ever made. The followup, Fantasia 2000, simply couldn’t compare.
Technically the movie was superb as well. Disney pioneered animation techniques in Fantasia which remained second to none for decades. The next major revision in animation was CGI.
Wow, what a movie.
I remember seeing “Fantasia” in a theater when I was about five years old or so (that would have been in 1951 give or take), and thinking the scene and the music were the most beautiful things I had ever experienced in my oh so very short life. The 30’s and 40’s Disney features were supreme, then, along with The Three Stooges (I was also entranced by Harpo Marx’s harp playing). Those are what triggered my love of music and art, I believe, even at that young age. These days, I’m not sure what inspires my grandchildren, but what I’ve seen and heard doesn’t encourage me.
Oops. By “scene and music”, I mean “Ave Maria”. Until then, I had never heard it.
“Even the greatest museum is still a graveyard.”
True, but reverence is learned there and nowhere else. Our experiences are our own personal museums in which we teach this to our children.
And leave Jersey alone!
I just finished reading Vincent Bugliosi’s book on the Kennedy assassination. What struck me (second only to the obviousness of Oswald’s sole responsibility) was, in the chapter on Ruby, how casual the relationship between cops and the public was in those days.
Ruby not only carried a pistol most of the time, he even got a police officer to buy it for him so he could save on the sales tax (about 5 percent). And on those occasions when Ruby got taken into custody for some minor alcohol-serving violation (club owners got those all the time), once he made bail, they’d give him his weapon back … even though no one but police officers could legally carry firearms back then.
They knew you, they trusted you implicitly. They didn’t treat everyone as if he were a violent felon.
That’s what I miss about the black-and-white days. Relationships were everything.
I echo the sentiment: this may be one of the best Bleats yet. Nostalgia (happen to be writing about it myself at the mo) is apparently both an antidepressant and an aprodisiac neurochemically–and rhe image of the Mouse you cite as middle brow? Nahhh dude, that’s the first chunk out of the Berlin Wall between high culture and low, the Jenga piece slowly slid out so the whole towering division could come crashing down. The second Disney came into being popular culture became sophisticated. Fantasia proves it.
Geez James,don’t overthink this,okay? It’s just detritus from the past and we
like looking at it. Bleatniks are smart enough to know that a Swingin’ Kodak Ad
did not represent ‘real life’ then any more than an iPhone Ad does now. (Really, people need an application that turns the phone into a LEVEL?)
So,keep scanning weird stuff you find in flea markets…we can handle the
time travel and not read too much or too little into it.